Foot and Mouth & Ms. NewKirk
© Baxter
Black, DVM
published in The Draft Horse Journal, Autumn 2001
What
kind of person would wish Foot & Mouth disease on animals?
“I openly hope it comes here. It will bring economic
harm only for those who profit from giving people heart attacks
and giving animals a concentration camp-like existence...," said
Ingrid Newkirk, president of PETA (animal rights group).
I have received many letters from indignant readers who
are aghast at Ms. Newkirk’s insensitivity and mean
spiritedness. It was surprising to me, too. I guess I assumed
that there are some lines they would not cross.
But then it hit me. Her comments really had nothing to do
with animal suffering, no, she was mocking us. Her group’s
marketing strategy, which they readily acknowledge, is to
shock, i.e., comparing serial murderer Jeffery Dahmer to
the meat packing industry, suggesting we drink beer instead
of milk, or erecting billboards saying, “Jesus was
a Vegetarian.”
Those were well thought out advertising campaigns designed
to attract attention. And when a group is not restrained
by any normally accepted standards of “civility,” they
test the limits of the public’s disgust.
They are the National Enquirer of animal rights, the man
on the corner in a raincoat flashing passersby, the Dennis
Rodman, Madonna and Geraldo of newspaper filler pieces, the
Jerry Springer and Jackass of activist cable TV. They are
the goons at the football game mooning the camera.
Unfortunately, in our modern world we are so bombasted with
full color, full volume, never ending sensationalistic info
entertainment including such profound tragedies as Afghani
oppression, African AIDS, Korean famine, mass murder, fire,
flood, earthquake and terrorism, that we are numb.
Ms. Newkirk must constantly be trying to stick out amidst
the blizzard of chaos, greatness and acts of heroism that
compete with her in the public’s eye. It gets harder
and harder for her to shock us.
So reign in your sense of outrage, say a prayer for our
fellow livestock raisers in Europe and leave Ms. Newkirk
to her petty cruelty. She is no different than the guy selling
souvenirs outside the gates of Timothy McVeigh’s execution.
Nothing is sacred to a zealot. |